The Argument For Complete Abolition Of The Use Of Animals...

In this essay I will outline and defend the argument for complete abolition of the use of animals in biomedical research. I will ultimately agree with Tom Regan’s claim that â€Å"the fundamental wrong is the system that allows us to view animals as our resources.† I will describe DeGrazia’s and Carruthers’ important objections to Regan’s claim as well as Regan and Singer’s responses. I will show that none of the objections overcomes Regan’s central argument. 1) Regan’s Argument: Regan states that the use of animals in research assumes that their value is reducible to their possible utility relative to the interests of others. Regan states that it is wrong for us to use animals to be eaten, exploited for money or sport, or surgically manipulated. Regan has a Kantian view of how we should treat animals in research and in general. The possible utility of animals approach shows that people believe that we have no duties directly to animals, that we owe nothing to them, that we can do nothing that wrongs them. One problem with this view is that it is anthropocentric and does not take account of the possible sufferings of other species. Animals are subject to painful and inhumane treatment during biomedical research and testing, they have entered into a contract that they have not given contest to. The violation of animals’ rights means that decisions are made for them, and usually do not benefit them. It is wrong for humans to decide what should be done wi th animals. The use ofShow MoreRelatedIts Time for a More Responsible Approach to Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation1387 Words   |  6 PagesThe debate about using animals for medical testing has been ongoing for years. The struggle is usually between extreme animal rights activists and scientists. The animal rights activists believe animals should never be used for research, and the scientists believe any use of animals is acceptable. Listed below are factual historical accounts of animal use, statistics, and arguments against the use of animals. In ancient Greece animals were used for the study of life science. To learn aboutRead More A More Responsible Approach to Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation1506 Words   |  7 Pagesto Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation The debate about using animals for medical testing has been raging for years. The struggle always seems to be between extremist animal rights activists who believe that animals should never be used for research, and scientists who believe that any use of animals is acceptable. There are a growing number who argue that there must be a reasonable middle ground. I contend that there must be a significant decrease in the number of animals usedRead MoreThe Hypocrisy Of American Slavery1666 Words   |  7 PagesFrederick Douglass gave a speech entitled â€Å"The Hypocrisy of American Slavery,† slavery was still a prominent feature of American society, especially in the Southern States. Douglass, like many others, was an abolitionist, someone who advocates the abolition or ending of something, such as slavery. Douglass’s speech was intended to shine a light on what he called the hypocritical practice of slavery within the United States of America. Lyndon B. Johnson on th e other hand, was the 36th president of theRead MoreFrederick Douglass : A Fugitive Slave And A Free Man1192 Words   |  5 Pagesdepriving them of an education.[] By doing so, slave owners reduced their slave’s state of mind to that of an animal, unable to think, speak and advocate for themselves. After reading â€Å"The Columbian Orator,† in particular the Dialogues Between a Master and Slave by John Aikins, Douglass understood the â€Å"pathway from slavery to freedom;† becoming educated.[] Fredrick Douglass provides the strong argument that in order to achieve physical freedom, a slave must achieve mental freedom. Through knowledge and anRead MorePros And Cons Of Nuclear Weapons Essay1996 Words   |  8 PagesSince nuclear weapons came into production, the question regarding their abolition has been on the minds of many global citizens. Nuclear weapons are described as being, â€Å"†¦ the most destructive, inhumane and indiscriminate weapons ever cre ated. Both in the scale of the devastation they cause, and in their uniquely persistent, spreading, genetically damaging radioactive fallout† (icanw.org,n.d.). Their disastrous nature would make anyone think that the answer should be a unanimous â€Å"yes†, but in factRead MoreEssay on Capital Punishment Cheapens the Value of Human Life1588 Words   |  7 Pagesremains a divisive, polarising and emotionally charged subject abundant with passionate conviction from both retentionists and abolitionists: it is ridden with morally persuasive arguments on both side of the fence. It was as far back as in 1830, that the Marquis de Lafayette vociferously stated: â€Å"I shall ask for the abolition of the punishment of death until I have the infallibility of human judgment demonstrated to me†. Why? The following quote by Stewart J sums it up perfectly in that: [T]heRead MoreEmancipation and Apprenticeship3508 Words   |  15 Pagesquestioned whether slavery was right but they still practiced it. They argued that slavery although wrong was necessary in order to develop their empire and to convert heathens to Christians. The Bible itself was ambiguous enough for Europeans to use it as the foundation for supporting slavery e.g.: the story about the curse on Ham and his posterity and their ‘blackness’ giving them inferiority and making them slaves forever. 18th Century Attitudes to Slavery In the 18th century, thereRead MoreThe Life Of Frederick Douglass, An American Slave1917 Words   |  8 Pagesmovement. In Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave, Douglass many stories to portray the horrors of slavery. The narrative consists of Douglass’ life as a slave, and his path to freedom. The story also doubles as a persuasive argument, written in hopes that one day slavery would be abolished. Douglass is born a slave and spends much of his childhood discovering what it is to be enslaved. During this time growing up, he only sees the horrors of slavery. As he becomes older, DouglassRead MoreThe Destruction Of The Second Temple1558 Words   |  7 Pageswas originally offered in the Jerusalem Temple (Sanders 2016). They sacrificed animals to gain peace and forgiveness, and the animals were distributed among the priest, the altar and the worshipper after the ritual slaughter (Sanders 2016). The exile disrupted the religious identity of Jew ish people that was closely tied to their native land, the place that was seen as YHWH’s house. The captivity resulted in the abolition of their temple, which led to the changes in their religious practices as JewishRead MoreAnalysis Of The Book Uncle Tom s Cabin 1827 Words   |  8 PagesSlave Law is a set of â€Å"laws passed by the United States Congress in 1793 and 1850 to provide for the return of slaves who escaped from one state into another state or territory.† Throughout the book, Stowe uses many examples to show the link between slavery and religion, emancipation/abolition and religion, and the values of capitalism. To begin with, the link between slavery and religion starts with Stowe writing for an overall religious and Protestant audience, Stowe shows that the system of slavery